Chicago’s move to increase its cloud computing tax from 9% to 11% has sparked concerns about the future of the city’s tech industry. As a long-time observer of the tech world, I can’t help but feel a sense of déjà vu. We’ve seen similar tactics before, and the outcomes were far from promising. While this may seem like a quick solution to the city’s budget problems, the implications could be far-reaching and ultimately detrimental to Chicago’s economic health.
This is not an argument against taxes in general. The issue at hand is the targeted nature of this tax, which singles out a rapidly growing and essential sector—cloud computing. The hope is that by taxing this high-demand service, the city will raise funds without losing businesses. Unfortunately, history shows that this approach rarely yields the desired results. In fact, it often backfires, as companies are quick to relocate when faced with unfavorable tax environments, taking both their business and the tax revenue with them.
The math behind Mayor Brandon Johnson’s proposal seems straightforward. The city faces a $1 billion budget deficit, and an additional $128 million in revenue from cloud computing taxes appears to be a viable solution. However, this oversimplifies the situation. Cloud computing is not a luxury item that can easily be avoided, like an expensive watch or handbag. It’s integral to the daily operations of countless businesses across industries. Additionally, cloud services are decentralized—companies are not tied to a specific location, and they can—and will—move their operations elsewhere if the financial burden becomes too great.
Chicago has long positioned itself as a potential tech hub, with initiatives to rival Silicon Valley. However, despite some successes, such as Google’s massive investment in downtown real estate and record-breaking startup funding in 2022, the city is losing ground. Major players like Citadel, Boeing, Caterpillar, and Tyson Foods have already pulled out, and the recent tax hike could accelerate this trend. The message is clear: businesses are already hesitant, and this move may only push them further away, especially with the looming threat of higher taxes.
At a time when cities like Denver and Washington, DC, are also experimenting with taxing cloud computing, Chicago risks isolating itself further. Tech entrepreneurs and companies are making decisions based on more than just immediate costs—they’re considering long-term stability and an environment that supports growth. The reality is that when businesses decide to relocate due to burdensome taxes, they do so quietly, and cities like Chicago are left wondering what went wrong. The city may not realize what it’s losing until it’s too late.