U.S. antitrust enforcers are initiating an inquiry into the intricate relationships between major artificial intelligence startups, including OpenAI (the creator of ChatGPT), and tech giants such as Amazon, Google, and Microsoft. This move comes as these companies exert substantial influence over the burgeoning generative AI sector, contributing to the increased demand for advanced chatbots like ChatGPT and other AI tools capable of generating innovative imagery and sound.
Lina Khan, the chair of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC), emphasized the focus of the inquiry during a Thursday AI forum, expressing concerns about potential undue influence and privileged access enabled by the close ties between dominant tech firms and AI developers. The market inquiry will specifically scrutinize the investments and partnerships formed between AI developers and major cloud service providers.
To gather comprehensive information, the FTC issued “compulsory orders” to five companies, encompassing cloud providers Amazon, Google, and Microsoft, as well as AI startups Anthropic and OpenAI. Microsoft’s long-standing association with OpenAI is widely recognized, while Google and Amazon have recently entered multibillion-dollar agreements with Anthropic, a San Francisco-based AI startup founded by former OpenAI leaders.
Google, in a statement welcoming the FTC inquiry, subtly criticized Microsoft’s OpenAI relationship and its history of facing antitrust scrutiny, highlighting the importance of companies offering openness and avoiding the historical practice of customer lock-in, particularly concerning AI services. This inquiry reflects growing regulatory attention to the intricate dynamics between tech giants and AI startups, aiming to ensure fair competition and prevent monopolistic practices in the rapidly evolving AI landscape.
Microsoft’s corporate vice president for competition and market regulation, Rimy Alaily, has expressed the company’s willingness to cooperate with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and defended its partnerships with AI startups as beneficial for competition and innovation. Amazon, Anthropic, and OpenAI have chosen not to comment on the matter.
Both the European Union and the United Kingdom have indicated their scrutiny of Microsoft’s investments in OpenAI. The EU’s executive branch suggested that this partnership might trigger an investigation under regulations related to mergers and acquisitions that could harm competition across the 27-nation bloc. Similarly, Britain’s antitrust watchdog initiated a review in December.
Antitrust advocates have welcomed actions taken by both the FTC and European authorities, characterizing these deals as quasi-mergers. Matt Stoller, director of research at the American Economic Liberties Project, highlighted how major tech firms, unable to acquire top AI companies, resort to exerting influence in less formal ways.
Microsoft has never publicly disclosed the total dollar amount of its investment in OpenAI, describing it as a “complicated thing,” according to Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella. He emphasized the substantial nature of their investment, which goes beyond monetary contributions and includes resources such as compute power.
OpenAI’s governance and its relationship with Microsoft faced scrutiny last year following the sudden firing and subsequent reinstatement of CEO Sam Altman. The tumultuous events led to stabilization efforts, including behind-the-scenes maneuvers over a weekend, championed by Nadella and other Microsoft leaders, ultimately resulting in the resignation of most of OpenAI’s previous board members.
Under the new arrangement, Microsoft secured a nonvoting board seat in OpenAI, with CEO Satya Nadella emphasizing that Microsoft doesn’t have control. The governance complexities arose from OpenAI’s nonprofit origins dedicated to safe AI development, transitioning into a for-profit entity.
Microsoft’s initial $1 billion investment in OpenAI in 2019, predating the introduction of ChatGPT, involved a partnership where Microsoft supplied computing power for training large language models, and, in return, gained exclusive rights to the technology. Nadella likened it to traditional commercial partnerships, emphasizing distinct corporate identities and mutual reinforcement.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC), signaling its intent to scrutinize AI tools’ development and use for almost a year, is now investigating the relationships between tech giants and AI startups. FTC Chair Lina Khan has underscored the focus on broader market consolidation and the potential dominance of a few AI leaders. The inquiry, approved unanimously by the three Democratic commissioners, requires companies like Microsoft, Amazon, and Google to provide details on partnership agreements, strategic rationale, decision-making processes, and key resources involved in AI system development within 45 days.