As developers increasingly delve into the intricacies of cloud infrastructure, the concept of Infrastructure as Code (IaC) has emerged as a key enabler. While the majority of developers may not currently embrace IaC, there is a notable shift among the top echelon, the 10% to 15%, who recognize its significance in modern development technologies. Pioneering this movement, companies like Pulumi are championing a language-first approach to IaC, breaking away from traditional domain-specific languages (DSLs) and offering developers the familiar constructs of their preferred programming languages.
The Evolution of IaC: From Requesting Resources to Owning Infrastructure
In the bygone era of developers requesting resources from IT, the realm of infrastructure remained distant, with a clear separation between application code, infrastructure ownership, and server management. However, the evolution of distributed computing, propelled by virtual machines, containers, and Kubernetes, thrust developers into the core of cloud infrastructure concerns. The principles of “shift left” and “you build it, you own it” underscore the profound shift where developers now shoulder responsibilities extending beyond application code to encompass infrastructure management.
The Rise and Evolution of IaC: A Journey Through Time
While Infrastructure as Code may seem like a contemporary trend, its roots extend back over 50 years, encapsulating the fundamental principles of automating infrastructure. The movement gained momentum in the 2010s, with tools like Puppet, Chef, and Ansible introducing IaC methods for configuring virtual machines. However, it wasn’t until the maturation of public cloud platforms and the dominance of Kubernetes that IaC entered a new era. HashiCorp’s Terraform, AWS CloudFormation, and Azure Resource Management emerged as flag bearers, introducing novel abstractions and domain-specific languages.
Challenges in DSL Evolution: Pulumi’s Critique and Multilanguage Infrastructure
Pulumi CEO Joe Duffy posits that the evolution of IaC, particularly the adoption of DSLs, may have taken a wrong turn. Believing that every DSL tends to grow into an inadvertently poorly designed general-purpose programming language, Duffy argues that the complexity of the cloud ecosystem challenges DSLs, YAML, and markup languages. Pulumi advocates for a multilanguage approach, supporting Node.js, Python, Go, .Net, and Java. This approach aligns with developers’ desires to use familiar languages, eliminating the need for artificial complexities and enabling a seamless integration of cloud resources into existing programming languages.
Python and AI: Catalysts for Language-First IaC Adoption
As the industry experiences a surge in interest in Python and artificial intelligence, the appeal of a language-first approach to IaC intensifies. Pulumi emphasizes that treating developers with “kid gloves” when it comes to the cloud is a mistake, highlighting that IaC can turn the entire cloud into a programmable set of building blocks. The battle between DSLs and general programming languages in the IaC space gains new significance in the AI era, where Python becomes a powerful tool for developers navigating the complexities of infrastructure while seamlessly integrating it into their primary language.
In the ongoing debate over DSLs versus general-purpose programming languages in the IaC domain, Pulumi stands as a proponent of empowering developers to leverage the language conventions they are already familiar with, offering a more natural and elegant approach to programming cloud infrastructure.