Searching for a separator inside a text value looks simple until the separator is missing, repeated, or located at an unexpected position. A report that assumes every value follows the same pattern can quietly classify malformed data as ordinary input.
Oracle’s INSTR function returns the position of a matching substring. The useful part of the design is deciding how each possible result should affect the application.
Read the returned position correctly
Oracle positions characters starting at one. When INSTR finds a match, it returns the starting position of the requested occurrence. When no match exists, it returns zero.
The optional starting position and occurrence arguments control where the search begins and which match is requested. Their defaults are both one.
For example:
SELECT INSTR('TEAM-204', '-') AS separator_position
FROM dual;
The result is 5. A search for the same separator in TEAM204 returns 0.
That difference should remain visible in subsequent logic. Zero is a meaningful “not found” result, not the position of a character.
Make the expected format explicit
Suppose an import process expects a code containing exactly one hyphen. Before extracting or interpreting its parts, classify the structure.
An illustrative expression is:
CASE
WHEN code IS NULL THEN 'Missing value'
WHEN INSTR(code, '-', 1, 2) > 0
THEN 'Multiple separators'
WHEN INSTR(code, '-') = 0
THEN 'No separator'
ELSE 'One separator'
END
Oracle’s searched CASE expression evaluates conditions in order and returns the result associated with the first true condition. That makes it suitable for expressing this classification directly in a query.
The example checks for a missing value before examining the separator. It then distinguishes repeated separators from a single occurrence.
Do not confuse a structural check with full validation
A value such as -204 contains one separator, but it has no prefix. Likewise, TEAM- contains no suffix.
Whether those values are acceptable depends on the code’s specification. A separator count alone cannot establish that the entire identifier is valid.
Write down the format rules: permitted prefix values, acceptable suffix length, allowed characters, and whether surrounding spaces are meaningful. Implement the rules that the business process actually requires.
Avoid introducing assumptions simply because the first few sample records happen to follow them.
Build a small test set before using production data
Include a normal code, a code without a separator, a code with two separators, a leading separator, a trailing separator, and a missing value.
For each case, record the expected classification. This creates a reviewable agreement between the person defining the data format and the person writing the query.
If a system receives values from several sources, include examples from each source. A pattern that works for one import may not describe another.
Preserve the original value during investigation
When identifying problematic records, show the original code beside its classification. This makes corrections easier to review and avoids hiding the evidence behind a generic error label.
Use the classification to guide the next step: accept, correct, or refer for investigation. INSTR supplies a location; the surrounding query should explain what that location means for the task.
Sources:

